Oatmeal Cream Pies
Choose an available window
Available in 2 availability windows. Next up: Friday Pickup • Oct 23, 2026.
Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies sandwiched around a smooth, sweet vanilla cream filling. A nostalgic favorite with cozy cinnamon and brown sugar flavor in every bite, just like the classic treat you remember, but made from scratch in small batches.
Details:
- Full-sized, bakery-style cream pies (approximately 4 inches in diameter).
- Best stored in an airtight container at room temperature and enjoyed within 3-4 days of pickup.
- May be refrigerated for up to 7 days.
Ingredients
Oatmeal Cream Pie
unsalted butter (pasteurized cream, natural flavor), all purpose flour (unbleached hard red wheat flour, enzyme.), powdered sugar (sugar, cornstarch), brown sugar (sugar, molasses), marshmallow creme (corn syrup, sugar, dried egg white, vanillin), oats, eggs, sugar, molasses, salt (salt, yellow prussiate of soda), vanilla extract (vanilla bean extractives, water, alcohol), baking powder (corn starch, sodium bicarbonate, sodium aluminum sulfate, monocalcium phosphate), baking soda, cinnamon
Allergen Information
Contains: Milk, Eggs, Wheat
Select Your Window
Choose an Option
Add to Cart
Review details in your cart and choose your payment method at checkout.
We respond quickly to confirm availability, pickup details, and payment.
Prefer personal service?
Use Contact for Next Availability when you need help with:
- Coordinating delivery or pickup beyond the default options
- Shipping inquiries (when available)
- Custom designs, flavors, or dietary requests
- Large or recurring orders for events and wholesale